Long Island Weddings

Home › Vendors › Cakes and Dessert

Huntington wedding cake bakery

Catalina's Bake Shop

Catalina's Bake Shop is a wedding cake bakery in Huntington that says it serves Long Island. It publishes no prices on its own site.

cake bakeryLong Island
catalinabakeshop.com

What Catalina's Bake Shop says it offers

“We pride ourselves in creating the best artisanal pastries, cakes, custom treats and authentic empanadas” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

“We offer five different types to serve the flavors you are craving for: pulled pork, beef, chicken, sausage and vegetable” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

“Inquire about our party trays.” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

“gluten-free flourless chocolate cake” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

Catalina's Bake Shop publishes no prices on its own site

We read catalinabakeshop.com for a rate, a package price or a minimum and found none. The only figures we found are on a marketplace, labeled below.

“$700 starting price” Source: weddingwire.com (WeddingWire, marketplace).

“Buttercream frosting $6.50 per slice (without tax); Fondant $7.50 per slice (without tax); Cupcakes $4 per cupcake (without tax)” Source: weddingwire.com (WeddingWire, marketplace).

The terms it puts in writing

“To place a standard cake order, submit requests 1 week before the event and for large tiered cakes or sculpted cakes, 2 weeks notice is required, as well as a 20% deposit.” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

“Mon, closed” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

In its own words

“I was fortunate enough to be chosen as the head decorator at a luxurious hotel on Long Island, where I dedicated over a decade of my life to perfecting my craft.” Source: catalinabakeshop.com.

On its service area, the site says “1155 E Jericho Turnpike Huntington, NY 11743” Source.

Ask before you sign

  1. What is the price per slice or per tier for my guest count?
  2. Is delivery and setup included, and is there a fee to my venue?
  3. Can we taste before booking, and is the tasting free?
  4. Does my venue charge a cake cutting fee for an outside cake?
Is this your business? Claim this listing free to correct facts and add packages and current pricing. Paid placement, if you ever buy it, is always labeled.
Claim this listing

More cakes and dessert on Long Island

All 10 ›
Levittown
Dortoni Bakery & Pastry Shoppe

Established 1976 with five shops, and it supplies the standard cake package at 30 plus catering halls, upgrading at 50% off retail with a $9.99 tasting on its own site.

View
Smithtown
Alpine Pastry Shoppe

Alpine Pastry Shoppe at 59 Route 111 in Smithtown lists six standard flavors plus a gluten free cake, and sells cupcakes, cake pops, macarons and pastries for dessert buffets.

View
Islip
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery

Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery is a wedding cake bakery in Islip that says it serves Long Island. It publishes no prices on its own site.

View
West Sayville
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods

Audrey's Fine Baked Goods is a wedding cake bakery in West Sayville that says it serves Long Island. It publishes no prices on its own site.

View
Melville
Bake Me a Cake! by Angela

Melville based with eight cake flavors and eleven fillings on its menu, including pink champagne and tres leches, and a $300 starting price on WeddingWire.

View
Bohemia
No Gluten Kneaded

No Gluten Kneaded is a wedding cake bakery in Bohemia that says it serves Long Island. Its own site prints prices, starting with “Price ranges $30 to 75”.

View
Long Island Weddings
Every kind of Long Island wedding, in one place.
Back to Cakes and Dessert