Home › Venues › Waterfront
Shelter Island is reached by ferry and only by ferry, which is the first thing to plan around at The Pridwin and the last thing anyone thinks about. The North Ferry and the South Ferry both stop running at night, your band's van has to make one of them, and so does every guest who is not sleeping on the property. The hotel was built between 1924 and 1926, opened in 1927 above Crescent Beach, and reopened in May 2023 after a long restoration with Cape Resorts joining the Petry family in ownership. Seven named spaces sit on about 10 acres.
No price exists on the record for this venue, first party or marketplace, which is unusual enough to state plainly. The hotel takes an RFP and quotes from there, and The Knot's listing carries no starting figure to sanity check it against. Expect the proposal to be the first number you ever see for this property.
We read the Pridwin page and its weddings page, the Cape Resorts weddings hub, The Knot listing and the Shelter Island Reporter's May 2023 reopening report, on 10 September 2026. Checked September 2026. First party means the venue’s own site or rate card; marketplace means The Knot, WeddingWire, Zola, Wedding Spot or similar. Nothing here is averaged or estimated.
Shelter Island is ferry access only, so the last boat sets the real end of the night, and the hotel's two own pages disagree on capacity, 200 against 150.
Nothing on the Cape Resorts site addresses ferry timing, and it is the single biggest logistical fact about a wedding here. Two operators serve the island. The North Ferry runs from Greenport on the North Fork. The South Ferry runs from North Haven near Sag Harbor. Both have a last boat.
Work backwards from that. Every guest who is not in a room on the property has to be on a boat by a specific time. That means your reception ends earlier than the contract allows, or a large number of people leave during the last hour, or you book beds for all of them. Vendors have the same problem in reverse, and a band that misses the last ferry is a band you are housing.
The hotel publishes no end time and no curfew. Shelter Island noise rules may apply and nothing is published about those either. Get the venue's own last boat advice in writing, since they solve this problem every weekend.
The Pridwin's own weddings page lists space by space maxima that top out at 200 on The Lawn. The Cape Resorts weddings hub, on the same company's website, says the property suits weddings up to 150 people. Both are first party. They disagree by fifty people.
The Knot goes higher still, putting the venue in a 201 to 250 band with dining figures of 100 to 230, which is marketplace and above both of the hotel's own numbers.
We are not choosing between them. What we would do with a list of 180 is send both page addresses to the events team and ask which sentence is current, because one of those pages is out of date and only they know which. A venue that answers that quickly and precisely is telling you something useful about how the rest of the planning will go.
The published spaces are The Lawn up to 200, The Terrace Restaurant up to 125, The Terrace up to 75 and The Grove up to 75. The Pool takes up to 75, The Frost Room up to 48 and The Morgan Room up to 40. All of it sits on roughly 10 acres above Crescent Beach.
Line those up and the constraint appears immediately. The Lawn is the only space that holds a large wedding, and the largest indoor room is the Terrace Restaurant at 125. A lawn wedding for 200 has no published indoor equivalent on this property. No rain plan is published and no tent is mentioned on the weddings page.
For a wedding of 120 or fewer that problem disappears and the property becomes flexible: a ceremony on the lawn over Peconic Bay, cocktails in The Grove or by the pool, dinner indoors if the weather turns. Ask specifically what the tent option is and who pays for it.
The name comes from King Arthur's shield. The hotel was built between 1924 and 1926 on a hill above Crescent Beach and Peconic Bay, opened in 1927, and the Petry family has run it since the 1960s. Cape Resorts joined the family in ownership and management and reopened the restored hotel on 6 May 2023, which the Shelter Island Reporter covered at the time.
What that means for a 2027 wedding is a property that has just been through a multi-year restoration rather than one that is due for one. Rooms, systems and kitchens are new or newly refurbished, and the operator runs other properties on the East End, so the events machinery is not being invented for your date.
On-site rooms and cottages are the other half of the appeal. On an island served by two ferries they are closer to a requirement than an amenity.
The weddings page publishes no per person rate, no site fee, no food and beverage minimum, no buyout requirement and no room block requirement. Booking runs through an RFP form or a central reservations number. The Knot listing carries no starting price either, which is rare, and it means there is genuinely nothing to compare a proposal against.
No service charge percentage appears anywhere. A reviewer on The Knot describes the contract as standard with no unusual additions, which is a reader's impression rather than a rate.
The Knot lists liability insurance as required and says food, catering, planning and service staff are offered in house. The hotel does not publish a vendor policy of its own. Because the property is a working hotel with a public restaurant, exclusivity is not stated and should not be assumed, and that is worth asking in the same breath as the ferry question.
Room blocks are the other unpublished term and the one most worth settling early. On an island with limited beds and a boat at either end, the number of rooms the hotel will hold for you, and until what date, shapes your guest list more than the lawn capacity does.
A three level Freeport waterfront building with a rooftop ceremony deck, listed on WeddingWire at $100 per person off peak and $110 in peak season.
Private beach and a fire pit on Great South Bay in Sayville, with a 4,700 sq ft ballroom seating 350 and a separate 2,400 sq ft cocktail room.
Seven acres of gardens, waterways and fountains on Hempstead Harbor, running three reception rooms and taking weddings from a 60 guest minimum.
A 1909 mansion on Suffolk County parkland at the Great South Bay, capped at 205 guests, publishing $80 per person and a 22% administrative fee.
A working Oakdale seafood restaurant on Great South Bay with free deepwater docking, a 180 seat buyout and a published $129 per person starting rate.
A Bayville hall on Long Island Sound with 18 foot ballroom ceilings, one event at a time, and a Saturday guest minimum fifty higher than Friday's.